Monday, 27 October 2014

THE CORRUGATED IRON CATHEDRAL


It was the prettiest of hues trimmed with a refreshingly brisk lightness, modest but certain, calmly self-assured. It stood out as a beacon in the tiny village at the terminus of the fiord encapsulated by the steep, soaring, snowy mountains, the source of the feared avalanches. While most of the other timber buildings in this east-coast settlement were painted in strong blood reds, rich navy blues, luscious thick creams and deep dark greens all highlighted with dainty, white decorative trims, this timber-framed church in Seydisfjordur, Iceland was a surprisingly intense sky blue with the same cloud-white trim seen everywhere around the village: see - http://voussoirs.blogspot.com.au/2012/09/norwegian-wood-and-corrugated-iron.html
The colour looked like a Renaissance sky without the exuberant drama of radiant rays of golden light and angels. It was an unusual tint for Seydisfjordur that spends much of the year white, covered with a dazzlingly cold snow surrounding its fractured, frozen pond. In this context, the cathedral colour glowed with the luminance of light gleaming through the depths of an iceberg.




Arriving at Seydisfjordur





Appropriately the analogies - sky and luminance - have to do with the heavens and light, both metaphors and symbols of the church. Indeed this building does stand out from the rest, not only because of any cathedral spire height or detail, although this form is unique in the array of structural elements in the village; and not only because of its wonderful colouring, but also because of its considered location and siting. The church sits in amongst an ad hoc sprawl of roadways, tracks, lanes and paths, paved and otherwise for no apparent reason, that arc in layers around the fiord. In the midst of this unruly array, at the end of what one discovers to be a slightly skewed axial way, a little blue church is revealed. One knows that it is a place of worship as it has the familiar form of one of Wren’s London churches: a symmetrical gabled facade with a central spire on a stubby tower. The coherent formality of this organisation in the carefree collection of appendages and attachments of this settlement is surprising.








As one strolls around the village discovering its nooks and crannies, one slowly comes to realise that one is walking down a different, self-consciously patterned surface unlike any other in the village, one that has pavers in the centre with a bitumen surface either side. Looking up, the western elevation of the church can be seen closing the vista in the best of classical manners, enclosing public space with arched windows in a pale blue wall topped by a steep roof interrupted by a short spire on a tower base, with each portion separately framed in fine white. It is truly pretty, proud, complete with a quaintly delicate appearance and fine proportion and detail, glowing with a gentle certainty of being. It offered a startling contrast to the looming sky-scraping faces of the ancient, craggy, snow-capped geology that is its background - rock of ages. These massive mountains made the village look less than a miniature: thoroughly insignificant, minute.


The fiord from above

Looking down on Seydisfjordur at the end of the fiord

View of Seydisfjordur from the fiord

It is a beautiful placing for this spiritual centre, on the edge of town but linked formally to it, as if to mark its different importance in this random array of places that, at times, had a careless, ill-considered, frontier feel about it. As one gets closer to this Wren-like form with the expectation of it being made with the customary load-bearing, solid, rendered masonry seen in Britain, it is discovered that this church is clad in an unsophisticated corrugated iron and fitted with plain glass timber windows. The disparity with this familiar material that is usually used for sheds and shantytowns being used for the house of God was somewhat alarming, but, once the apprehension had been overcome, one realised that this material performed well. There was a surprising elegance here in this ‘lightness of being.’ Somehow the honesty seemed to overcome all preconceptions and offered a satisfactory whole that could be admired.




The apse on the eastern end of the church

One could accept the idea and respect the considered, astute detailing that created this little gem - proud and complete, standing boldly transparent in the harshest of harsh environments, celebrating its identity with a light-flooded interior that reminded one of Wren’s St. James in Piccadilly. It was when sitting in Wren’s church on one occasion that a local resident, who came with his lunch for the musical recital, turned to tell us that he loved the space for its unsullied, natural light. It was indeed beautiful, with no cringing stained glass ambitions. Wren had high walls of clear glass that let the light stream in even on London’s worst days: and so did the light in this tiny church at Seydisfjordur that ignored any rough reference its cladding might suggest to hold a quality that made it more cathedral than chapel, in spite of its size.







The building did not try to replicate the cliché pointed Gothic arch openings that churches seem to favour: see - http://voussoirs.blogspot.com.au/2012/09/corrugated-iron-chapel.html  In one way the church appeared Norman, but the points were there to transform this identity with a spikiness provided by the repeated gables that had been placed over each opening on both the north and the south walls and around the tower, a zigzagging capped with the fine point of the spire. This little building held authority greater than its size suggested. The corrugated iron gave it a ruggedness, an individuality that could be admired. This light metal material enclosed the building efficiently and cheaply, as it does on simple sheds and shacks. The ambiguity danced with a lovely contrasting twinness - house of God, shearing shed; rough edges, exquisite detail; hard steel wall, soft sky colour. It was a true delight. It does show how conditioned we have become with our cliché expectations. Could anyone familiar with shearing sheds, Penang shacks, and shantytown images ever anticipate a corrugated iron church or chapel? - see:

The tiny portico, almost Romanesque





Walking around closer to this little surprise, one could appreciate the detailing. It was complete and thorough. Flashings with corrugated wall sheeting always need careful attention if they are not to be messy or ineffective. Here, in this harsh climate, folk know how to seal a cladding and to protect horizontal ledges from the ravages of winter. All sills and joints were nicely considered and resolved, especially those around the arches, surely one of the most difficult of details to achieve; but it was neatly managed here.





Although this settlement is remote even for this island - it is a region that Lonely Planet oddly called ‘The Empty East’ in its travel guide on Iceland - the requirements for disabled access had not passed this place by. These rules make their own demands when there is a need. While it might have been expected that Workplace, Health and Safety issues would have loomed large in the village fishing industry, the general demands on access for those with a disability might possibly not have yet had an impact on this region; but no. The sweet set of stairs rising up pyramidally, Aztec-like, to the tiny entry portico of this church had been supplemented with a ramp. One could get along it, possibly with some care, but it would be a precarious journey with such a narrow ply deck with a mid-landing return and no balustrades. It seemed that the locals might have heard about access but not seen any of the standards. At least this modest wooden structure did not impose too much on the church entry even if it was the equivalent of a wheelchair tightrope ride.

The access for the disabled
The only handrail is on the steps

Turning from this church, one was immediately thrust into the ad hoc clutter of this village that held other gems in its messiness like pearls in seaweed. These structures were the Norwegian prefabs  - timber-framed, corrugated iron-clad, well insulated - that had been brought over for the fishermen in the early 1900s in the best ‘Ikea’ tradition. It is truly remarkable that these buildings remain in such a good state of repair in this most rugged of remote places that has such a treacherously punishing climate. They are a joy to behold – a scattered set of nearly sixty buildings that formed the core of this place that the Lonely Planet, in spite of the ‘emptiness’ of the region, nominated as the most beautiful village in Iceland. It certainly has a magnificent church that has the presence of a cathedral: see - http://voussoirs.blogspot.com.au/2014/10/the-most-beautiful-building-in-world.html


For more on shearing sheds,see:
and
http://voussoirs.blogspot.com.au/2014/02/deeargee-gostwyck-shed-and-chapel.html



P.S. 28 October 2014
The Old Library at Queen's University, Belfast is a grander building than the little church at Seydisfjordur, but it has a similar form, with an array of gables on the side elevations around a main gable roof form.

Sunday, 26 October 2014

PAIRS 12 - SHEARING SHEDS: ISIS DOWNS & DEEARGEE


On Friday 24th October 2014, ABC News carried an article on the Isis Downs shearing shed: see -
http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2014-10-24/isis-downs-shearing-shed-celebrates-100-years/5836456 and below.
The images were a surprise. They immediately brought to mind the Deeargee shearing shed at Gostwyck that had been written about earlier in the year: see -http://voussoirs.blogspot.com.au/2014/02/deeargee-gostwyck-shed-and-chapel.html 
Both sheds had a similar, unusual geometrical form.

The ABC report was interesting because of the amount of detail on the building that was included. The text is reproduced here for the record with a link to the Deeargee shed review.



West Queensland's iconic Isis Downs Shearing Shed celebrates century with rare open day
By Chrissy Arthur
UPDATED FRI OCT 24 08:57:20 EST 2014

The Isis Downs shearing shed is open today between 9am and 5pm.
A renowned shearing shed in Queensland's west will open its doors to the public for one day only as it marks its centenary.
Construction on the Isis Downs shearing shed, a semi-circular woolshed at Isisford, south of Longreach, began in 1913 and was completed in 1914.
It has a unique design and is known as one of the largest early twentieth century shearing sheds.
Isisford is also holding horse races tomorrow, and the Isisford Race Club has worked with the station's owner to enable visitors to tour the woolshed today between 9:00am and 5:00pm.
Visitors were once able to view the building, but it has been off limits for a number of years.
Engineer historian Ian Waples has researched the shed and said it was the only example of its kind in Australia.
"Well I think what is special about it is the design to start with, it's very unusual the design, it is a semi-circular shed," he said.
"The original design was a 52-stand shed, so it was a massive exercise [to build].
"It's all steel construction, except for the floor and that is very unusual in woolsheds, they are usually just all timber.
"This one has got a centre pole in the middle of the structure and all the trusses radiate out from the central pole, so to be inside it, it is a really magnificent building."
Mr Waples said it would also have been a huge challenge to build.
"All the steel was brought out from England, Australia at that time didn't have any steel mills, so the steel was all brought out to Melbourne, fabricated in Melbourne, shipped to Rockhampton, then via rail, out towards the site, and then by teamsters to the property," he said.
"It was really a magnificent effort when you think back 100 years.
"For that area, it must have been an eye-opener to see such a magnificent building going up."
The Isisford Race Club secretary Sally Edwards said today's opening may also encourage more visitors to attend tomorrow's race meeting.
"We have a lot of tourists come through and they ask about the shed all the time," she said.
"It is disappointing [that it's not open] but we just appreciate that we do have this time.
"It is one of our historic icons in this community, it is our history, and it is something that we are proud of."
An extra horse race has also been listed on the program at the Isisford race meeting, to celebrate the centenary of the Isis Downs shearing shed.
100 year old shed was well ahead of its time
Property manager Phil Dearden, from Consolidated Pastoral Company, said the shearing shed was a special building.

"It's 52 stands - so certainly that would have been a significant number of sheep that would have gone through in a day," Mr Dearden told ABC Country Hour.
"It was the first electric shed too, as far as I know in Australia - electric overhead gear - so it was pretty well ahead of its time.
"It was a pretty unique set up for the time, and it is a unique shape, so I guess that is what makes it what it is."
The Pastoral Company has not used the shed for shearing for 10 years following a move out of sheep, but said it has remained in good condition.

POSTED FRI OCT 24 08:09:35 EST 2014

http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2014-10-24/isis-downs-shearing-shed-celebrates-100-years/5836456 


Isis Downs shearing shed interior

The Deeargee shearing shed interior

 The Deeargee shearing shed 





http://voussoirs.blogspot.com.au/2014/02/deeargee-gostwyck-shed-and-chapel.html 

The Isis Downs shed has radial trusses to frame the roof. The Deeargee shed is far more inventive and uses an 'umbrella' type of central support to carry the roof framing without any central column.
One has to ponder the origins of these sheds. Horbury Hunt is very likely to have been associated with the Deeargee building. The Isis Downs shed was fabricated in Melbourne. Are there any prototypes that these buildings were modelled on, or did they both originate from an idea based on improving light and ventilation in the hot Australian summers?

For more on shearing sheds, see:

Andrew Chapman, Woolsheds, The Five Mile Press, Victoria, 2011
and
Andrew Chapman, Around the Sheds, The Five Mile Press, Victoria, 2012
Both books have a collection of photographs of shearing sheds with a short introduction and a commentary on each location.